Specialty Pizzas
Hand-tossed pizzas with fresh toppings and signature combinations. The New Yorker is a customer favorite.
- 12-cut and other size options available
- Fresh daily-made dough
- Generous topping portions
At a Glance
Pizza Plus stands out in Butler's dining scene for their generous toppings, fresh ingredients, and consistent quality that has earned loyal local following. Customers consistently praise their New Yorker pizza and Italian hoagies, though delivery timing and order accuracy can occasionally vary. The restaurant combines authentic pizza craftsmanship with friendly, community-focused service.
- Generous pizza toppings
- Fresh, quality ingredients
- Friendly owner and staff
- Great hoagie selection
Why Customers Choose Pizza Plus
Based on 251 customer reviews
- Signature New Yorker pizza with bacon, pepperoni, and green peppers
- Fresh hoagies made with quality meats and toppings
- Family-owned restaurant with personal service
- Available through multiple delivery platforms
- Homemade desserts including chocolate chip cookies and brownies
- Customizable pizza cuts and sizes
Location & Local Context
Address: 206 New Castle Rd, Butler, PA 16001, USA
Phone: (724) 283-7333
Hours: Friday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Monday Closed, Sunday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Tuesday 4:00 – 8:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Thursday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Wednesday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Parking: Free parking available in front of restaurant
Peak times: Friday-Saturday 6pm-8pm, Sunday 4pm-7pm
Nearby neighborhoods: Meridian, Butler Township, Connoquenessing
Nearby landmarks: Near Butler Memorial Hospital, 5 minutes from downtown Butler, Close to Butler County Community College
Services & Offerings
Hoagies & Sandwiches
Italian hoagies, steak and cheese, and other hearty sandwiches made with quality ingredients.
- Available in small and large sizes
- Fresh vegetables and quality meats
- Customizable with full works or specific toppings
Sides & Appetizers
Loaded fries, salads, and other appetizers to complement your meal.
- Cheddar and bacon fries
- Fresh salads with choice of dressing
- Perfect for sharing or as meal additions
Delivery & Takeout
Convenient ordering through multiple platforms and direct pickup options.
- Available on Uber Eats and Slice app
- Direct phone ordering available
- Quick preparation times
Customer Reviews
⭐ 4.2 out of 5
251 total reviews
Most Frequently Mentioned
- Fresh ingredients (89 mentions)
- New Yorker pizza (67 mentions)
- Friendly service (54 mentions)
- Quality hoagies (41 mentions)
Rating steady at 4.2 stars over last 6 months. 18 new reviews this month.
★★★★★
“The New Yorker ( bacon, pepperoni, and green peppers), Italian hoagie w/works ( small ), Steak & Cheese hoagie ( large ) and Fries with cheddar & bacon. Everything was very delicious, and fresh! Tasted fabulous 👌”
— Corina★★★★★
“Would recommend Pizza Plus to anyone. Great food. Cool owner, polite employees. Definitely recommend.”
— Lawson Conner★★★★★
“I ordered The New Yorker, 12 cut and three chocolate chip cookies via Uber Eats. I wish I could review the cookies, but they were out. Being the amazing restaurant that this is, (and they couldn’t contact me directly) they substituted the cookies for brownies. The PIZZA. When I tell you it was the best pizza I have ever had, I MEAN THAT WITH MY SOUL. I actually feel bad for my son who is 2. He will be chasing this perfect pizza for the rest of his life. The brownies. WOW. These would put your grandma to shame! They were amazing! Thank you for a great meal!”
— Angel Wiley★★★★★
“Ordered from this place since the original owner opened the shop. Ordered a grandad yesterday and it was underwhelming. There wasn't any sauce at all hardly and the flavor was non existent. I feel that someone just slapped it together and sent it out the door. Unfortunately believe that the was the last of the business they will receive”
— Dutchieblaze412 **Frequently Asked Questions
Our New Yorker features bacon, pepperoni, and green peppers with generous toppings on fresh daily-made dough.
Yes, we're available on Uber Eats, Slice app, and other delivery platforms, plus direct phone orders.
We offer both small and large hoagies, with the large being perfect for hearty appetites or sharing.
Absolutely! We offer 12-cut and other size options to suit your preference.
Yes, we make fresh chocolate chip cookies and brownies that customers love.
Business Activity
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Weekend evenings 6-8pm
Daily specials: Fresh ingredients delivered daily
Popular this month: New Yorker pizza, Italian hoagies
Similar Businesses Nearby
Texas Roadhouse
⭐ 4.3 (2591) · 2.1 miles
101 Clearview Circle, Butler
Subway
⭐ 3.4 (100) · 1.3 miles
622 Moraine Pointe Plaza, Butler
Subway
⭐ 3.8 (130) · 1.3 miles
534 West Cunningham Street #A, Butler
Subway
⭐ 3.8 (126) · 1.9 miles
330 Greater Butler Mart, Butler
Rachel's Roadhouse
⭐ 4.4 (2274) · 1.7 miles
100 Fairfield Lane, Butler
Papa Johns Pizza
⭐ 4 (283) · 1.3 miles
541 West Cunningham Street, Butler
People Also Search For
- Pizza delivery Butler PA
- Best hoagies Butler Pennsylvania
- Italian food near me Butler
- Pizza restaurants Butler County
0out of 100
Online Visibility Score: Excellent
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
Reviews & Reputation32/35
Online Presence33/33
Business Completeness17/17
Engagement5/15
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
Powered by Buzza AI on Clover
Pizza Plus manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.